Beta Readers are More Important than You Think

You’ve successfully finished the first draft of your manuscript and are feeling pretty good about your story overall. Maybe you’re ready to take some time off before diving into revisions; or worse yet, you think it’s ready for editing. There is an integral piece of the revision process, however, many writers miss out on—beta readers. After proofreading your first draft, beta readers should be your next step.

Who Are Beta Readers?

Think of beta readers as test subjects, or guinea pigs, for your book. They are typically the first group of people to read your manuscript in its entirety. When you narrowed down your book’s target audience, beta readers should fall within that exact camp of people.

If the thought of narrowing down your target audience is still hard, choosing a broader spectrum of beta readers (male and female, larger swings in age groups, etc.) will help you narrow down your target audience to the exact group of people who should read and enjoy your book.

When deciding who might serve as beta readers for you, make sure they are comfortable providing you with honest and constructive feedback, enjoy reading in general, and also enjoy reading books within the genre you’ve written.

What Do They Do?

The key element of success when using beta readers is to ask them to take a high-level approach to your overall story, including plot, characters, pacing, and the manuscript’s readability as a whole. To ensure readers don’t stumble over spelling and grammar mistakes, do a full round of revisions on your work—especially focusing on mechanical errors—before you send your manuscript to anyone.

A beta reader is not the editor for your book and doesn’t take the place of one. Instead, beta readers merely test-drive your story.

10 Questions to Ask Your Readers

If you are looking for specific feedback from beta readers, send a checklist and a PDF version of your manuscript. A checklist will also keep your readers focused on the feedback you want. A few sample points to add to your checklist can include:

• Were you interested in the story?
• Could you relate to the main character?
• Did you feel drawn into the book from the very beginning? If not, by what page did you feel pulled in?
• Were any parts of the story confusing for you? If so, where were they?
• Did any of the material feel redundant or repetitive as you read?
• Do you think there was enough tension/conflict within the story?
• Was the dialogue on the light side or did you feel there was too much dialogue?
• How about description—too much or not enough?
• What did you think about the number of characters? Did you find there were too many to keep track of or not enough?
• What is one item not on this checklist you feel I could do to improve this book overall?

Free Download: Beta Reader Questions to Ask for Nonfiction, Fiction, and Memoirs/Autobiographies

Where to Find Beta Readers?

When looking for beta readers, consider finding three to four people. I believe anything less than three readers doesn’t provide enough feedback for writers to work with—especially if one reader comes up short with feedback. Readers can be found in many places, including your church or book club, as well as Goodreads groups and there are now several websites geared specifically toward beta reading.

You can also find readers on Instagram or Twitter. Use hashtags like #amwriting, #writinganovel, or #writingnonfiction to find other writers within your genre. Build a connection with them and then see if you can swap manuscripts to beta read for each other. I’m often hesitant to pull on family or friends to serve as beta readers. Feedback from readers is not simply to bolster a writer’s confidence but to find issues and while they can still be fixed and receive feedback from a testing group of your target audience.

5 Last Pieces of Advice for Success

1. Give your readers a deadline of no more than three weeks to return their feedback.
2. Send your manuscript as a PDF and send your reading checklist.
3. Take a step back from your manuscript during this time.
4. Follow up with beta readers about a week before the deadline you provided.
5. Remember that the criticism you receive from beta readers are intended to improve your manuscript so even more people will enjoy reading what you wrote.

Up next we are going to be talking about what to do with the constructive criticism and comments you get from those beta readers.